“To educate a person in mind and not in morals is to educate a menace to society.”
Theodore Roosevelt 1858 to 1919
Read the transcript
Steve 00:00
I got a question for you. How do you educate people in morals?
Jacob 00:04
I think the one answer for it is that whatever society you belong to has a retrospective view on many issues. And so if you said, for example, we know now that we had Jim Crow laws in the South, how many people, if the vote were put to them today, would say, let's bring them back?
Steve 00:40
Well, welcome to the Teach Different podcast, everybody. I am here with, of course, another great quote. This one's going to be by Teddy Roosevelt. I'm here with Jacob Plummer, who's actually a lifelong friend of mine. He's a health care executive.
And we met actually at Knox College in Galesburg, Illinois. So our careers have taken slightly different paths. I ended up being an educator and Jacob got into the... Well, you've done a lot of different things as well, Jacob, the health care industry and leading companies, etcetera. So I'll let you...
You know, maybe when you weigh in first on the claim of the quote we're going to use, you can introduce yourself as much as you'd like and give any details that you like. Well, here's our drill, of course. Quote claim counterclaim essential question storytelling. There's four moves to the Teach Different Method. And we're going to model it, of course, here.
On Teach Different's side, we're just doing a lot of exciting things now. And we're... We've got this community of teachers now that are giving conversations in their classrooms and reporting out on them about how they land with different types of students and different types of classrooms. So that's really, really exciting. And anyone listening now, we just encourage you to reach out to us and learn more about what we're doing because we have a lot of opportunities right now, and we want to share the wealth with the world.
So here is the quote. I'll read it twice. To educate a person in mind and not in morals is to educate a menace to society. Theodore Roosevelt. To educate a person in mind and not in morals is to educate a menace to society.
This is attributed to Theodore Roosevelt. And I'll talk a little bit more about what I learned about where it came from in a moment. But, Jake, feel free to weigh in on this quote.
Jacob 03:00
Would you like me to start with just the claim, like restating what I think it's saying? What
Steve 03:06
does it mean?
Jacob 03:07
Okay. Well, to me, what it means is that if somebody develops their intellect, that will develop a type of intelligence, an intelligence on how to do something complex, whether it be in chemistry or in war, whatever your subject is. But I think what the quote is saying is that society, a good society, a great society, is not a function of the capabilities that that society has, the technical capabilities. It is a function of something more than that. And I think that what Roosevelt, if this quote is from him, is saying is that it's morals.
And you can imagine a person who is very strong in a technical skill that is not strong in a moral skill. And I always have thought it interesting when you look at the Nazi era, how you had tenured faculty at Ivy League universities in The United States throwing their reputation behind the Nazi government. And you think, gosh, does anybody think that they weren't intelligent? Does anybody think that they weren't intellectually at the top? I think you must conclude that they were intellectually at the top.
And so if you say that you think that the Nazi society is not just, of course there's some people, presumably Nazis, that would say it was just, but there are some who will say it's not, then how does that compute? How can you have very intelligent people endorsing and advocating for a society that is not just? There must be something lacking. And I think that what that lacking is probably defined here is morals.
Steve 05:09
And it's surfacing in the quote. To educate a person in mind, the faculty in this case, and not in morals is to educate a menace to society. So at the risk of putting words in Roosevelt's mouth, it sounds like what he's saying to push this, if you just educate someone's skill sets, like their intellect, and you forget about what it means to be a good person and getting them to think about that, you're actually creating a Frankenstein's monster. You're doing something that is, I mean, it's going to be a problem.
Jacob 05:51
Yeah. Even if you were a true moral relativist and you said there's no difference in your opinion between the Nazi philosophy and, let's say, a non racist philosophy, okay, even if you were a relativist and you said, I'm fine with either one, The quote still works, right, because the Nazi would say, Well, somebody intelligent that's arguing against Nazi society is not imbued with the right ethics. Because the Nazis had a sense of ethics,
Steve 06:25
right? We,
Jacob 06:27
a non racist society, looked at the Nazi ethics. That was the problem, is that it was fundamentally a disagreement about people, about who counted as a human being and what rights a human being deserve. And so you could say regardless of what your society is, somebody that's not educated in the ethics of that society is a menace to it.
Steve 06:52
Yeah. I didn't... I I really did not take it there. That's true. I mean, if you take this literally, you know, I guess each society defines itself in its own way and what it it believes in.
And you're right. It could make the same mistake. You get really smart people in that aren't buying in to the ethos and the morals of society, and they do become a menace. They they they go against the society. Let me read what I learned about this quote just specifically because we're we try to be as precise as we can with where these quotes came from.
Jacob 07:33
Okay.
Steve 07:34
And to be transparent, I wasn't able to find this quote in any speech, letter, book from Roosevelt. Okay, so that's why we stick with the attributed to Roosevelt. Yeah. A lot of people would say that this is something that he would say. And here was the most interesting thing that I read about it.
On 04/23/1910, there was something called the sore bone speech. I don't know if you've heard of it, and I don't even know, S O R B O N N E.
Jacob 08:12
A great university in France, in Paris.
Steve 08:15
Okay. And I'm sure I said it wrong. But he argued in that speech, Roosevelt, that ability without moral direction makes a person more dangerous and that talent should be judged by whether it serves good or evil. Is that not powerful? So, you know, in that speech, he was he was kind of addressing some of the things we've already started to bring up, which makes it believable that you could attribute a quote like this to him.
You know, talent is not what it's all about. You need to think good and evil. You need to think morals before you're gonna argue that someone's good for society and not a danger.
Jacob 09:01
Can I read you a quote from Theodore Roosevelt?
Steve 09:04
Of course.
Jacob 09:05
I think you'll find it relates.
Steve 09:07
The more the merrier.
Jacob 09:08
If brilliant genius comes without the accompaniment of the substantial qualities of character and soul, then it is a menace to the nation.
Steve 09:20
Oh, that's even closer. When did he say that?
Jacob 09:22
It's closer. Well, I think you're gonna like this. He said it in April of nineteen o three, and you were talking about where we met at Knox, and we both spent time at the University of Chicago.
Steve 09:38
Yes.
Jacob 09:39
And Theodore Roosevelt laid the cornerstone at the University of Chicago Law School. When he did that, the day he did that, he gave this speech. So this speech was given at the University of Chicago on the day that he was there. So I... And I think that this may be the speech that this quote comes from because the phrase menace to is is Exactly.
Yeah.
Steve 10:06
Well, that's... I'm gonna blame ChatGPT.
Jacob 10:10
Sometimes you just have to go with a local obsessed Theodore Roosevelt
Steve 10:16
fan. I'm gonna go to Jake for anything Theodore Roosevelt related. That is absolutely has to be it. But we say attributed, so I guess it's not completely like verbatim. So we're gonna say attributed, but we're gonna put attributed in bold.
Okay, so let's read it again. Educate a person in mind, not in morals, is to educate a menace to society. We're in the Claim portion, right? Storytelling is a big move in the Teach Different Method. So I'm going to ask you, Jake, if you can think of maybe a person in your experience just growing up or maybe an observation that you well, you've already actually brought up the observation of the Nazi regime, but maybe even something closer to home that speaks to this, you know, and if it ends up going against it, that's okay.
You can get us into the counterclaim as well. But what do you have? Is anything coming to mind?
Jacob 11:19
Just to continue the World War II references, you know, at the end of that war, when the threat from Europe was no longer present, The United States perceived a great threat from the Soviet Union. And at that point, there was a sense that whoever controlled space would be in a dominant position. And we did not have the rocket scientists that we thought would allow us to really be the leaders. And so we brought in the rocket scientists from the conquered German Nazi rocket program. And we brought them to The United States, to Huntsville, Alabama, and they were involved in building up the NASA program.
And in many ways, us being able to land on the moon was a... I mean, to get to the moon, you need to have a really big rocket. So it was demonstrating that we were the leaders in rocket technology. Now, you could argue, without going into the details of who those scientists were, because I know somebody will present one of them that had always longed to be an American citizen and had a picture of Abraham Lincoln up on their wall in Berlin and such. But for the most part, if you accept that they were probably as dedicated to the Nazi administration as the average person in a position of high power, you would say, Well, they weren't imbued with our ethics.
You know, they weren't imbued with our philosophy, with an anti racist philosophy. But they were pretty useful, weren't they, to our society? So, you you-
Steve 13:07
Why did they go? Why did they come to our society? Was it... Did they have any choice? I mean, could we argue it was a moral choice for them to come back?
Jacob 13:17
I don't know the details of all of them, but my understanding was that if you were that prominent, you might find yourself facing charges, postwar charges, you know, what, you know-
Steve 13:29
Let's not give them too much credit. They they ended up, you know, saving themselves by coming here.
Jacob 13:34
Okay, might have been... It might have been very clear that this is the... Where you'd want your bread to be buttered. Know, I mean, you're a rocket scientist, you can be put in charge of a very important program, or you could say no and to what end, you know?
Steve 13:48
Very talented. The point is they were extremely talented. And what did they do? They helped us.
Jacob 13:55
Yeah. So I think that you could say that in that case, they were not a menace, right? They were a boon. Now, you know, it's because we maybe contained their energies and we said, You're going to focus on our rocket program. If they had been focusing on the Soviet rocket program, we might say, They're not a boon.
But I think that that maybe does introduce the idea that you can take somebody of great technical skills and have them advance the strength of your society.
Steve 14:34
And if your society is good, you can argue that that has a good outcome. The talent helped you achieve a good outcome from your society. Did you educate them in morals? Absolutely not. You could actually argue, you saved them from their own immorality.
Jacob 14:56
Yeah, they they gotta get out of jail. Free card.
Steve 15:00
Okay. I mean, that's a valid counterclaim in that case, you know.
Jacob 15:06
And if you wanted to expand upon it, you might say, well, the only reason maybe that somebody needs to be imbued with the values of your society is if they are able to self guide themselves, to make their own decisions. You knew with certainty that they would not participate in anything that could be destructive, then maybe you wouldn't need to worry so much about their education, you know, about their being imbued with these values.
Steve 15:38
Yeah, right. Let me take another angle on this. And I think it's the counterclaim that I'm going to get into here. But I also think that I'm going to start introducing an essential question or two that will help me understand this. And again, for everybody, first time listeners on how this method works, questions, they come naturally when you're thinking about the tension between the claim and the counterclaim.
And one came up here and that's my question is, what does it mean to educate a person in mind? Okay. I could ask the moral one as well. And that actually, that's my next one. But I'm just asking myself this because we've thrown around the word like talent, being very skilled at doing something.
Like you educate someone's mind and they're very talented at something. And that's a believable definition. You know, but I'm going to throw in that there's a way to educate someone's mind by, and we can talk about this, Jacob, because Knox College and liberal liberal arts colleges, they teach you how to be a quote free thinker. Okay? There's a way to educate the mind that doesn't necessarily train it to be really good at building rocket ships or figuring out fission and fusion and is highly technical, but your mind develops in a way where you have a very broad understanding of things.
And, you know, if you're like Socrates, you might end up getting to the point where you end up, you know that you know nothing, okay? You're so open minded that you're able to consider really a lot of different types of ideas and you're very empathetic. Anyway, I don't know if it's a skill, but it's an education of the mind that is a free thinking education that I would call different than these more technical ones that we've brought up. So that was a long way of saying this. I've always believed that if you can educate somebody to be open minded and a free thinker, that morality, an aspect of morality, follows with that, meaning you become good naturally when you think a certain way.
And I'll stop there. I mean, feel free to challenge me on this, Jake, because I think that Roosevelt might challenge me on this as well, but I'm going to throw that out and say that there might be a way of thinking of education and the mind where you don't have to worry. It is morality. The right thing to do is to be free thinking and open minded and empathetic and not judgmental. That's, I guess, my attempt at a counterclaim.
Can you speak to that?
Jacob 19:13
You're saying that they're fused together. There's really separating education in mind and And morality. Yeah. Really cannot be split apart from
Steve 19:23
Yes. Each That's the counterclaim.
Jacob 19:26
I think that what you would have to believe, if you believed that that was true, is that with the education that you're describing, one could not be a menace to society. Of course, the question is who is taking the role of society? And when you give the example that you gave, how did Socrates' society perceive him?
Steve 19:58
Oh my goodness. Listen to this. I've got another way to tweak the counterclaim, and you just brought it out. To educate a person in mind and not in morals is to educate a useless person to society. I would call Socrates, the best critic of him would be he's useless.
Philosophers, people who think a lot, they're useless to society. They end up not really contributing. Now, I wouldn't call that a menace. You know, I think that's a little rough to call that a menace, but I think this is where I'm gonna come back to the claim and agree with Roosevelt and say, if you're not talking morals and you're not talking about the right and the wrong thing to do, and you become really, really smart or free thinking or whatever, you might not feel like you need to help people or do anything, no responsibilities to anything. You're just, you know, you're just like a grifter, right?
Like you just do your own thing and you have no, but again, I wouldn't call it a menace because this is a pretty strong statement here. Like it's always bad Because I don't... And that kind of brings up another question I have. But did that did that tweak make any sense? I think
Jacob 21:26
so. I mean, I think that you're... If you imagine a scenario where there are a 100 men and you only need 80 in order to keep the invaders repelled, then 20 of them could be, as you say, useless and not lead to a worse outcome because you have the 80 that are there. If you needed 81, then having 20 of these... At the margin, that one person has probably stopped being in the useless category and started to be in the we have a problem category.
That's where I think that whether somebody is useless or a menace is probably dependent on how needed they are at that time. So that's probably a judgment call. How needed is everybody?
Steve 22:19
That's a good... Okay. I get that. I get that. I got a question for you.
This is gonna be an essential question. This this is absolutely one here. How do you educate people in morals?
Jacob 22:33
That's a really excellent question. I think that the I think the one answer for it is that whatever society you belong to has a retrospective view on many issues. And so if you said, for example, we know now that we had Jim Crow laws in the South, how many people, if the vote were put to them today, would say, let's bring them back? Now I think that most, like, majority, probably I would say a high majority of people across the political spectrum would say, no, I don't want to bring them back. Well, why not?
Because many of those people's grandparents and great grandparents were part of living with them, maybe even encouraging them or suffering under them. So what changed? I think that what's changed is the education that people have had. You know, I heard it say once that if you took a child that was born today in, I don't know, McKinney, Texas, and you beamed back to the Viking communities of old and you could somehow drop off that kid, then twenty years later, they might be pillaging a village on the English countryside. And if you took a little Viking baby and you brought them forward in time to be raised in McKinney, Texas, they might be growing up to be an orthodontist.
And the idea is that it's not necessarily intrinsic within us how we will behave. It's the programming that we receive from the society that we're in. And so that's how you educate on morals, I think.
Steve 24:35
The environment.
Jacob 24:36
The environment.
Steve 24:37
Yeah. The environment. And this is making me... You know, maybe our our next conversation together, we can maybe drill down into that one a little bit more and whether or not there is something innate about who we are and the types of choices we make, or if perhaps it is all environment. And we're all the same, essentially.
I mean, any of us, we got transplanted into anyone else's life, you know, it's hard to argue that we wouldn't have made the same choices.
Jacob 25:15
Yeah, well, it's not to say that everything is purely relativistic, because what I think it starts to get to is why does your society believe what it believes? And if the society has arrived at this through debate, through reason, through questioning, through evaluating the other paths and determining whether there's merit in those other paths or not, then I think it's a much more considered... You might not have reached the ultimate truth. Right? So it'll be a lot of of things that need to be thought through and discussed and figured out.
But I think that that... A society that has approached its idea of the good by trying to evaluate itself against other options and then being able to explain why it's choosing the options that it had is probably the strongest in terms of being able to explain why it has the views it has. And and then they can constantly be under discussion or debate. But at least you're debating something. If you're debating somebody who says, I'm right because I'm right, then it's not going to be much of a debate.
Steve 26:27
That's like might makes right. But, yeah, I mean, it... It's funny. A society in a way has a morality. You can have an opinion about a society's good or badness.
Just like we have an opinion about a person's good or badness. And I feel like the difference, of course, not only is one an individual and the rest of society, but it comes down to the idea of choices. Right? An individual makes choices. And that Viking who ended up growing up in McKinney, Texas, yeah, his environment would have been completely different than being a Viking.
And who knows, maybe he would have made different choices, even though he would have had the same society that was supporting him and vice versa in the other direction. That's an open question. And then society itself, when a society makes choices, it's kind of a conglomeration of, well, what's the law? What's the structure? How do decisions get made?
Is there a balance of power? Or is it like you're saying, someone saying, I'm right because I'm right. You know, it's might makes right here. That's the choice that's made. Or is it debate and you get to hear other views and then there's collaboration and compromise, etc?
But I'm little I'm droning on a little bit. Before we end, share something about Theodore Roosevelt, Jake, because he's one of your... You know, the people you know the best. Share something about him that you just think people need to know that they probably don't know.
Jacob 28:17
Well, I'll tell you one of my of my favorite stories about him. Though it's the type of story that made me happy, I was not an adult citizen when he was president. He's the type of person I really am happy to read about as somebody who was in charge in the past, because I think that I would have been a little apprehensive if I had been living through his administration of, Boy, my God, is this going to work out? And now I can enjoy it because I know that things worked out. He wanted to be able to say to the world, The United States is no longer a small country that is an afterthought on world affairs.
We are a leading country. We will have a seat at the biggest tables. And to signal that, he wanted to send the US Navy all around the world. And our Navy was painted battleship gray, as navies tend to be. He painted all them white.
All the ships were white. They were gleaming. They were called the great white fleet, and it made a really beautiful striking image, you know, coming across the horizon. The only problem is he did not have allocated enough money to actually pay for the great white fleet to travel around the world, as he... As was his vision.
But he did have enough money to send the fleet halfway around the world. So he sent the fleet halfway around the world, And he asked Congress for the money to bring them back. Now, were all these people in Congress that did not want him to do this. And he said, Well, they can make their own decision. If they want to keep the Navy on the other side of the world, then that's fine with me.
And so he really did force the head of Congress. You know me, I don't actually really like it when presidents do things like this to Congress. I think that we're way too lopsided in the power of the presidency to the power of the Congress. But if you're going to do it, I guess do it with some style. And also, have the benefit of knowing that it did all work out at the end of the day.
That's extortion.
Steve 30:19
That's moral extortion. You're going to desert our Navy. I mean, come on.
Jacob 30:26
That's right.
Steve 30:28
That's great. And he was just, I mean, from what I know about him, he just had a really rare balance because, and I have to ask this. Yeah. Give me his contribution to the environment. Because a lot of people, you know, associate him with being very heavy handed, kind of a power broker, got us into some armed conflicts.
Yeah. And you don't associate that with a pro environment person these days. Usually, those are existing in different types of people. But tell me what you know about that, and then we'll we'll wrap.
Jacob 31:09
Well, it's true. He was... I mean, nobody wanted the Spanish American War probably more than Theodore Roosevelt. But he also did win the first Nobel Prize for bringing an end to the Russian Japanese War. So I think that he was involved with peacemaking as well.
I would say there's a lot of examples of the type of things that he did, one that were imperious, by the way, that helped the environment. I think there's a story of him yelling to his attorney general, Is there any law that keeps me from declaring this area to be a reserve? I think it was Canary Island, if I remember correctly. It's been a really long time since I read any of this stuff. And he heard, No, I don't think so.
He said, Well, so declared, you know? And he was writing executive orders.
Steve 31:52
What does that sound like?
Jacob 31:54
Go That's why you have to be careful when you deal with personalities like this. But I'll tell you what I think he did for the environment, is that he cared enough about it to understand what he was talking about. And so if you go and you look at the publications that are of Theodore Roosevelt, you'll find a lot of things that he wrote about politics and policy, which you wouldn't be surprised by that. He also wrote essays on nature, on naturalism. He was sending specimens to the Natural Museum of History in New York from the time he was a child all the way to being an adult, he was known for being able to have discussions with leading scientists of his time on different matters of ecology and the environment animals and such.
And so I think that that's probably
Steve 32:56
That's unique.
Jacob 32:57
Think that's important. When there's a lot of controversy about an issue, one of the big questions, especially nowadays, is is somebody virtue signaling? What's called virtue signaling, which means they don't really care that much about the issue. They just want to kinda seize the high moral ground. Or do they really know about this issue and care about this issue?
And I think Theodore Roosevelt would be put in that latter category. And I think that actually adds a lot to any movement when people are speaking with conviction and are well informed.
Steve 33:28
Thank you for that. I learned about Theodore Roosevelt and the quote, to educate a person in mind and not in morals is to educate a menace to society. I think safe to say this was a man of morals.
Jacob 33:48
That's right.
Steve 33:49
Thank you for coming. This won't be the last, and thank everybody who attended the Teach Different podcast. We'll be back soon. Take care.
About the quote
Theodore Roosevelt (1858 to 1919) served as the 26th President of the United States (1901 to 1909) and wrote extensively on education, citizenship, and character. This line is attributed to him across quote collections but appears in none of his published work, suggesting it may be a summary of his views rather than his actual words.
Our guest

Jacob Plummer
Healthcare Executive