Plato – Honesty


“No one is more hated than he who speaks the truth.”
PlatoBig Idea
Everybody hates to be lied to. When that happens, we feel anger and disappointment. There is betrayal and a loss of trust. Enemies are created. But there is another kind of hate we feel when somebody tells us the truth, especially if it is a truth that we don't want to hear. It's that feeling we get when a teacher calls us out for not trying our best, or when a parent catches us breaking the rules. In those cases, we don't want to hear the truth and we take our anger out on the messenger. Sometimes honesty hurts more than lies.
Claim
Telling the truth creates enemies.
Counterclaim
Telling lies creates enemies.
Essential
Question
Should we tell the truth?